Comparison of different platelet count thresholds to guide administration of prophylactic platelet transfusion for preventing bleeding in people with haematological disorders after myelosuppressive chemotherapy or stem cell transplantation - The Cochrane Library
Findings from this review were based on three studies and 499
participants. Without further evidence, it is reasonable to continue
with the current practice of administering prophylactic platelet
transfusions using the standard trigger level (10 x 10
9/L) in the absence of other risk factors for bleeding.
Plain language summary
Platelet
transfusions are used to prevent bleeding in people with low platelet
counts due to treatment-induced bone marrow failure
Review question
We
evaluated the evidence about whether platelet transfusions given to
prevent bleeding in people with lower platelet counts (for example 5 x
10
9/L or below) were as effective and safe as the current standard (10 x 10
9/L or below), or whether higher platelet count levels (20 x 10
9/L or below, 30 x 10
9/L or below, or 50 x 10
9/L or below) were safer than the current standard (10 x 10
9/L
or below). Our target population was people with blood cancers (for
example leukaemia, lymphoma, myeloma) who were receiving intensive
(myelosuppressive) chemotherapy treatments or stem cell transplantation.
Background
People
with blood cancers may have low platelet counts due to their underlying
cancer. Blood cancers may be treated with chemotherapy and stem cell
transplantation, and these treatments can cause low platelet counts.
Platelet transfusions may be given to prevent bleeding when the platelet
count falls below a prespecified threshold platelet count (for example
10 x 10
9/L), or may be given to treat bleeding
(such as a prolonged nosebleed or multiple bruises). Giving platelet
transfusions at a lower prespecified threshold platelet count may
increase the chance that bleeding will occur, which may be harmful,
whereas giving platelet transfusions at a higher prespecified threshold
platelet count may mean that people receive unnecessary platelet
transfusions. Platelet transfusions can have adverse effects and have
cost and resource implications for health services, so unnecessary
transfusions should be avoided.
Study characteristics
The
evidence is current to July 2015.
We found no new studies in this
update of the review. This review identified three randomised controlled
trials that compared giving platelet transfusions to prevent bleeding
when the platelet count is 10 x 10
9/L (the
current standard) or below versus giving platelet transfusions to
prevent bleeding at higher platelet count levels (20 x 10
9/L or below or 30 x 10
9/L
or below). None of the studies compared a lower trigger or alternative
trigger to the current standard. These trials were conducted between
1991 and 2001 and included 499 participants. Two trials included adults
with leukaemia who were receiving chemotherapy. One trial included
children and adults receiving a stem cell transplant.
Two of the
three studies reported sources of funding. Neither of the studies that
reported funding sources were industry sponsored.
Key results
Giving
platelet transfusions to people with low platelet counts due to blood
cancers or their treatment to prevent bleeding when the platelet count
was 10 x 10
9/L or below did not increase the risk of bleeding compared to giving a platelet transfusion at higher platelet counts (20 x 10
9/L or below or 30 x 10
9/L or below).
Giving platelet transfusions to prevent bleeding only when the platelet count was 10 x 10
9/L
or below resulted in a reduction in the number of platelets given. We
found no evidence to demonstrate that giving a platelet transfusion when
the platelet count was 10 x 10
9/L or below
decreased the number of transfusion reactions compared to giving
platelet transfusions at higher platelet counts (20 x 10
9/L or below or 30 x 10
9/L or below).
None of the three studies reported any quality of life outcomes.
Findings
from this review were based on three studies and 499 participants.
Without further evidence, it is reasonable to continue using platelet
transfusions to prevent bleeding based on the current standard
transfusion threshold (10 x 10
9/L).
Quality of the evidence
The
evidence for most of the findings was of low quality. This was because
participants and their doctors knew which study arm the participant had
been allocated to, and also the estimate of the treatment effect was
imprecise.